1. MINUTES OF A MEETING OF THE SENATE OF SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY HELD ?
      2. Present: ? Saywell, W.G., Chairman
      3. Brown, R.C. Cleveland, W.L.
      4. Chant, J.F. Feliman, M.
      5. Coleman, P. Hamilton, W.M.
      6. DAuria, J.M. McAllister, H.
      7. Kimball, M. Valentine, C.
      8. LeBon, C. Vining, A.
      9. Love, C.E. Weinberg, H.
      10. Nair, K.K. (replacing G. Geen) Pinfield, L.T.
      11. Rainey, R.J.S. In attendance:
      12. Rieckhoff, K.E. E. Alderson
      13. Roberts, M.C. R. Blackman
      14. Grant, B., Recording Secretary 0. Underhill
    1. S.M.06/Ol/86
      1. Page 2
      2. The Agenda was approved as distributed.
      3. 2. ? Approval of the Minutes of the ODen Session of Janu1iy-64986
      4. The Minutes were approved as distributed.
      5. There was no business arising from the Minutes.
      6. 4. Retort of the Chairman
      7. a) ? Pa p er S.86-1 - Engineerin g , Science
      8. Moved by R. Saunders, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
      9. S.M. 06/01/86
      10. Page 3
      11. Question was called, and a vote taken.
      12. Amendment moved by T. Wells, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
      13. S.M.06/O1/86
      14. Page 4
      15. 16 opposed
      16. S.M. 06/01/86
      17. Question was called on the main motion, and a vote taken.
  1. i!UIJ1ksJ!w'J
      1. Moved by R. Saunders, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
      2. 12 in favour
      3. 18 opposed
      4. e) ? Paper S.86-5 - Ethnic Relations Di p loma Program
      5. Moved by R. Saunders, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
      6. / f) ? PaDer S.86-6 - Fine and Performin g Arts
      7. Moved by R. Saunders, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
      8. S.M. 06/01/86
      9. Page 6
      10. . ) change
      11. prerequisites for FPA. 131-3, FPA 230-3, FPA.. 430-5 and FPA. 439-5
      12. S.M. 06/01/86
      13. Page 7
      14. Moved by R. Saunders, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
      15. j) PaDer S.86-10 - Business Administration
    1. k) Paver S.86-ll -Education
      1. Moved by R. Saunders, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
      2. Practice of Implementation"
      3. S.M.06/O1/86
      4. Page 8
      5. a) Paoer S.86-12 - Computin g Science - Proposed Enrolment Quota
      6. Moved by G. Ivany, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
      7. b) Paper S.86-13 - Criminolo gy Enrolment Management Plan
      8. Moved by G. Ivany, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
      9. Criminology
      10. S.M. 06/01/86
  2. Page 9 .
      1. iii) SENATE GRADUATE STUDIES COMMITTEE
      2. a) PaDer S.86-14 - English
      3. Moved by B. Clayman, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
  3. • language. A dictionary will be permitted. It is possible
    1. to waive this requirement only with the permission of
      1. the Graduate Program Committee.
      2. b) Pat*r S.86-1 5 - GeoraDhy
      3. Moved by B. Clayman, seconded by S. Verdun-Jones,
    2. S.M.06/Ol/86
      1. Page 10
      2. Graduate curriculum changes in the Department of Geography:
      3. i) Reduction of M.A./M.Sc. course requirements for the
      4. thesis option -
      5. To: a minimum of 12 credits and (a modified and renumbered) GEOG 800;
      6. iii) The quantitative requirement for GEOG 407 be changed -
      7. To: GEOG 704 (Human Geographers) or GEOG 706 (Physical Geographers);
      8. S.M. 06/01/86
      9. GEOG 721-4 Biogeography of Wetlands GEOG 723-4 Climatology
      10. of Food Production
      11. GEOG 745-4 Multinational and Regional Development GEOG 747-4 Transportation
  4. . xi) The exoectation that doctoral students present a
      1. seminar on a non-thesis related topic is to be replaced
    1. by a re q uirement that doctoral students present a
      1. S.M. 06/01/86
      2. Page 12
      3. Moved by B. Clayman, seconded R. Brown,
      4. S.M. 06/01/86
      5. Page 13
  5. • That Senate approve and recommend approval to the
      1. Board of Governors, as set forth in S.86-16, the proposed
      2. Ia) Admission of Graduate Students be changed
  6. . History. A third two-semester seminar may be
      1. S.M. 06/01/86
      2. Page 14
      3. iv) Programs of Study for the Ph.D. be changed
      4. S.M. 06/01/86
      5. Page 15
  7. • length, and will consist of two or three questions to be
    1. chosen from a broader list. A "fail', pass", or pass
      1. vi) History Graduate Courses changed - To:
      2. S.M. 06/01/86
      3. Page 16
      4. HIST 863-5 Colonial Administration in Africa HIST 864-5 Tropical Africa
      5. HIST 897-5 Supervised Readings
      6. HIST 898 M.A. Thesis/M.A. Extended Essays HIST 899 Ph.D. Thesis"
    2. (Secretary's Note: (i) ? Denotes new courses; (ii) The following
    3. courses will be deleted: lIST 805-5, 827-5, 835-5, 836-5, 851-5).
      1. Parer S.86-17 - Political Science
      2. Moved by B. Clayman, seconded by R. Brown,
      3. S.M. 06/01/86
      4. Page 17
      5. e) ? Pacer S.86-18 - Psychology
      6. Moved by B. Clayman, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
      7. S.M. 06/01/86
      8. Page 18
      9. v) Degree Requirements:
      10. Required Courses for the Experimental Program
    4. MEMO.
      1. Moved by B. Clayman, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
      2. To: An introduction to the theory of block designs, finite
      3. geometries and related topics"
      4. There was no other business.
      5. There were no notices of motion.
      6. The next regular meeting of Senate is scheduled for Monday, February 3, 1986.
      7. The Assembly moved directly into Closed Session at 8:55 p.m.

.
DRAFT UNTIL APPROVED BY SENATE
MINUTES OF A MEETING OF THE SENATE OF SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY HELD
?
ON MONDAY, JANUARY 6, 1986 KLAUS RIECKHOFF HALL, 7:00 P.M.
OPEN SESSION
Present: ?
Saywell, W.G., Chairman
Almassy, E.
Absent: ?
Archer, B.
Basham, G.
Berggren, J.L:
Brown, R.C.
Cleveland, W.L.
Cercone, N.
Dobb,T.C.
Chant, J.F.
Feliman, M.
Coleman, P.
Hamilton, W.M.
Clayman, B.
Hoegg, J.L.
DAuria, J.M.
McAllister, H.
Flynn, G..
Muscroft, J.C.
George, D.A.
Nielsen, V.
• ?
Goodman, D.
Noonan, M.
Graham, G.A.C.
Salter, L.
Hoiweg, B.
Scott, I.
Ivany, J.W.G.
Singh, M.
Kazepides, A.C.
Steele, A.G.
Kennedy, P.E.
Str ate, G.
Kimball, M.
Valentine, C.
LeBon, C.
Vining, A.
Lo, N.K.
Warsh, M.
Love, C.E.
Weinberg, H.
Marx, R.
Nair, K.K. (replacing G. Geen)
Pinfield, L.T.
Rainey, R.J.S.
In attendance:
Rieckhoff, K.E.
E. Alderson
Roberts, M.C.
R. Blackman
Saunders, R.
R. Cameron
Tay,P.
T.COhIi
Tuinman, J
.
R. Hayter
Verdun
-J ones ,
S.
I. Hutchinson
. ?
Wells, E.J.
J. Little
Heath, W. R., Secretary
W.S. Luk
Grant, B., Recording Secretary
0. Underhill

S.M.06/Ol/86
Page 2
The Agenda was approved as distributed.
19
PC
2.
?
Approval of the Minutes of the ODen Session of Janu1iy-64986
The Minutes were approved as distributed.
There was no business arising from the Minutes.
4.
Retort of the Chairman
The Chairman reported that the extended Christmas closing had not appeared to cause
any major problems. Some concerns had been expressed about the implications of such an
extended closing and the Chairman advised that a review would take place to look into such
concerns and to see if there were any negative consequences and costs as a result of this
action.
5.
REPORTS OF COMMITTEES
i) ?
SENATE COMMITTEE ON UNDERGRADUATE STUDIES
a) ?
Pa
p
er S.86-1 - Engineerin
g , Science
Moved by R. Saunders, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
That Senate approve and recommend approval to the
Board of Governors, as set forth in S.86-1, the proposed
curriculum revisions in Engineering Science'
It was noted that some of the Computing courses which were listed as prerequisites for the
Computer Engineering stream didnot reflect the changes made to Computing courses at the
last meeting of Senate and specific reference was made to CMPT 393 which no longer existed.
D. George advised that there had not been enough time to make changes prior to the meeting
but indicated intent to work out a resolution between now and the time that the course is to
be given.
Question was called, and a vote taken.
?
MOTION CARRIED
9

S.M. 06/01/86
Page 3
b)
Paoer S.86-2 - B.C. Studies Certificate Program
Moved by R. Saunders, seconded by R.C. Brown,
That Senate approve and recommend approval to the
Board of Governors, as set forth in S.86-2, the proposed
changes to the B.C. Studies Certificate Program'
Question was called, and a vote taken.
c)
Pa
p
er S.86-3 - Faculty of Arts Breadth Requirements
Moved by R. Saunders, seconded by R. Brown,
"That Senate approve and recommend approval to the
Board of Governors, as set forth in S.86-3, the proposed
revisions to Faculty of Arts breadth requirements"
MOTION CARRIED
E. Alderson joined the meeting to answer questions and provide further information.
T. Wells expressed concern that instead of broadening the education of students going
through the restructured Faculty of Arts, the proposal removed the requirement for study
outside the Faculty, in particular the Faculty of Science.
Amendment moved by T. Wells, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
"That the following be added to Point 1 of the proposed
Calendar entry for Breadth Requirements - "at least six of
which are outside of the Faculty of Arts" and the
appropriate editorial change be made to the subsequent
page"
Speaking against the amendment, E. Alderson pointed out that the current regulations do not
require students to take work outside the Faculty of Arts as the Group C requirement can be
satisfied by taking the Physical Geography courses which are located within the Arts Faculty.
He explained that the vast majority in Arts were very much in favour of students taking
Science courses but the amendment, if passed, would not accomplish that as students would
be able to choose from all Faculties.
K. Rieckhoff expressed disappointment that the original proposal of the Ad Hoc committee
which he felt had a solid rationale and dealt with the issue of breadth in a coherent manner
had been reduced to the proposal now before Senate. He felt the document expressed a clear
.
recognition by the Faculty of the importance and usefulness for students to take courses
outside the Faculty and failed to understand why the Faculty of Arts wished only to
encourage students to do so rather than to make a specific requirement. He urged Senators
to vote in favour of the amendment which he felt to be an improvement over the proposal.

S.M.06/O1/86
Page 4
Speaking. against the amendment, R. Brown pointed out that the present group requirements
were "bankrupt' because of smorgasbord actions taken over the years to accommodate
changes that have occurred in the University and had become so cumbersome and difficult to
administer that they were counterproductive to most students and to the faculty who were
trying to deal with them. With the introduction within the Faculty of programs from FIDS,
the Faculty no longer could be seen to be a tightly constructed group of similar
underegraduate teaching programs and had become a broad multidisciplinary Faculty. New
requirements were needed to reflect this new Faculty and it was felt there was no longer
any need to for students to take courses from outside Arts toget the kind of breadth felt to
be appropriate.
E. Alderson pointed out that the Ad Hoc Committee had dealt with the problem of breadth
requirements in Arts in two ways; the proposal now before Senate and a proposal for the
development of a Certificate in Liberal Arts which would create a structured program
demanding courses from the sciences and a number of other disciplines outside of Arts. This
second proposal was in the planning stages and would be brought forward to Senate at some
future point.
Following further brief discussion, question was called
on the amendment, and a vote taken.
?
AMENDMENT FAILEr
14 in favour
16 opposed
In response to an inquiry as to why Senate was considering the two proposals of the Ad Hoc
Committee separately, R. Brown replied that the proposed Liberal Arts Certificate will be
optional rather than a mandatory requirement and it was important for the Faculty to have a
set of regulations in place by Fall which reflect the new constituency and the new array of
programs within the Faculty of Arts.
C. Graham expressed opinion that the proposal diluted the current breadth requirements in
the Faculty of Arts as well as the breadth requirements associated with the B.A. degree in
Mathematics which he felt was undesirable and urged Senate to defeat the motion.
G. Flynn expressed belief that exposure to the sciences was needed in order to obtain a good,
basic undergraduate liberal arts education and she was very much opposed to the new set of
requirements for the Faculty of Arts which she felt, if passed, would do a great disservice to
future students at Simon Fraser.
Brief discussion followed in which R. Brown reiterated the point that students currently do
not have to go outside the Faculty of Arts to have exposure to the physical and laboratory
sciences and that the proposal was a coherent way of steering Arts students through their is

S.M. 06/01/86
Page 5
• ?
undergraduate program and that the existing set of requirements is incoherent and no longer
makes any sense.
Question was called on the main motion,
and a vote taken.

Back to top


i!UIJ1ksJ!w'J
Moved by R. Saunders, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
MOTION FAILED
12 in favour
18 opposed
"That
.
Senate approve and recommend approval to the
Board of Governors, that the following courses be deleted:
ARC. 473 Regional Studies in Archaeology: Africa
HIST 382 European Nationalism in Music and Opera
PHIL 243 Historical Studies in the Philosophy of Science"
Question was called, and a vote taken.
?
MOTION CARRIED
Senate received information that in the following instances, SCUS agreed that the response
received was sufficient justification to retain the course for the present, with the assurance
that those courses being retained while the curriculum is being actively reviewed, will be
subject to scrutiny in one year
(*denotes
such courses): ECON 490, GEOG 222, GEOG 418,
*GEOG 425,
*GEOG
475, G.S. 402, lIST 354, CHIN 340, FREN 491, ITAL 100, ITAL 101, SPAN
140, SPAN 350, SPAN 352, SPAN 447, POL. 434, S.A. 220, S.A. 352, S.A. 374, S.A. 394, S.A.
427, S.A. 476, S.A. 488.
?
e)
?
Paper S.86-5 - Ethnic Relations Di p
loma Program
Moved by R. Saunders, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
That Senate approve and recommend approval to the
Board of Governors, as set forth in S.86-5, the proposed
revisions to the Ethnic Relations Diploma Program".
Question was called, and a vote taken. ?
MOTION CARRIED
?
/ f)
?
PaDer S.86-6 - Fine and Performin g Arts
Moved by R. Saunders, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
"That Senate approve and recommend approval to the
Board of Governors, as set forth in S.86-6, that students

S.M. 06/01/86
Page 6
in the Fine and Performing Arts and Dance Major
programs be required to complete at least 24 credits
outside the Centre for the Arts"
0. Underhill, Centre for the Arts, joined the meeting to answer questions and provide
additional information.
It was noted that the entry on page 72 of the current Calendar appeared to be identical to
the proposal before Senate. 0. Underhill explained that substantial revision undertaken by
the Centre last Spring was not reflected in the Calendar and the issue of credit hours outside
the Centre had not been addressed at that time because the Centre was aware it would be
joining the Faculty of Arts and discussions in this regard were ongoing. Incoming students
currently do not have any regulations in place and the Centre therefore wishes as an interim
measure to put back this regulation until negotiations are complete with the Faculty of Arts
and the new Arts requirements are in place.
Question was called, and a vote taken.
?
MOTION CARRIED
Senate received information that the Senate Committee on Undergraduate Studies acting
under delegated authority at its meeting of December 10, 1985 approved (i) change of cours
number, title, description and prerequisites for FPA. 232-3 Scripting I; and (ii
.
) change
prerequisites for FPA. 131-3, FPA 230-3, FPA.. 430-5 and FPA. 439-5
ri
Senate received information that the Senate Committee on Undergraduate Studies acting
under delegated authority at its meeting of December 10, 1985 approved change of
prerequisites for the selected topics courses in Political Science - POL. 418-3, POL. 419-3,
POL. 428-3, POL. 429-3, POL. 438-3, POL. 439-3, POL. 448-3, POL. 449-3, POL. 458-3, and
POL. 459-3.
Eu
?
xii5
Senate received information that the Senate Committee on Undergraduate Studies acting
under delegated authority at its meeting of December 10, 1985 approved a change in
prerequisite for PSYC 210-3.
0

.
S.M. 06/01/86
Page 7
Moved by R. Saunders, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
That Senate approve and recommend approval to the
Board of Governors, as set forth in S.86-9, the change of
requirements for the Women's Studies Program'
Question was called, and a vote taken.
?
MOTION CARRIED
j)
PaDer S.86-10 - Business Administration
Senate received information that the Senate Committee on Undergraduate Studies acting
under delegated authority at its meeting of December 10, 1985 approved change of
prerequisite for BUS. 479-5 and a change of credit hours from 3 to 4 for BUS. 477.
k)
Paver S.86-ll -Education
Moved by R. Saunders, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
"That Senate approve and recommend approval to the
Board of Governors, as set forth in S.86-1 1, the proposal
to split EDUC 406-5 into two courses:
EDUC 406-5 - Supervised Observation and Teaching
EDUC 407-5 - Field Based In-Service: Theory and
Practice of Implementation"
In response to an inquiry as to whether or not students would be allowed to take both
courses for credit, J
.
Tuinman explained since there were two entirely different audiences for
each course he could not imagine any circumstances where that would occur. There was no
safeguard against that happening but such instances could be dealt with administratively.
Question was called, and a vote taken.
?
MOTION CARRIED
.
n

S.M.06/O1/86
Page 8
ii) SENATE COMMITTEE ON UNDERGRADUATE STUDIES/SENATE
COMMITTEE ON
ACADEMIC PLANNING
a)
Paoer S.86-12 - Computin
g
Science - Proposed Enrolment Quota
Moved by G. Ivany, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
• That Senate approve and recommend approval to the
Board of Governors, as set forth in S.86-12, the proposed
undergraduate enrolment quota in the School of
Computing Science"
W.S. Luk, Director of the School of Computing Science, and R. Cameron, Director of
Undergraduate Programs, joined the meeting to answer questions and provide further
information.
In response to concerns expressed about the effect this proposal on the Management and
Systems Science program in particular, R. Cameron briefly outlined how enrolment will be
calculated to determine the number of spaces available in various courses. Brief discussion
followed.
?
0
Question was called, and a vote taken.
?
MOTION CARRIED
b)
Paper S.86-13 - Criminolo
gy
Enrolment Management Plan
Moved by G. Ivany, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
That Senate approve and recommend approval to the
Board of Governors, as set forth in S.86-13, the proposed
enrolment management
p
lan in the School of
Criminology
Although he was in support of the motion, L. Pinfield expressed concern about the long term
effects and consequences of enrolment restrictions, particularly where those restrictions
were based upon grade point average and to those departments where no such restrictions
apply and he wondered if such issues had been addressed by SCUS or SCAP. G. Ivany
responded by advising that although the moral and social consequences were touched upon
he did not believe anyone could predict what the long range consequences were and th
these particular actions were being taken at the moment as a practical solution to a
immediate and impossible situation.
Question was called, and a vote taken.
?
MOTION CARRIED

S.M. 06/01/86

Back to top


Page 9
.
iii) SENATE GRADUATE STUDIES COMMITTEE
a)
PaDer S.86-14 - English
Moved by B. Clayman, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
"That Senate approve and recommend approval to the
Board of Governors, as set forth in S.86-14, the proposed
change in the graduate programs in the Department of
English:
M.A. Program - Language Requirement -
TO: All students registered in the M.A. program will be
required to demonstrate a reading ability in one language
other than English that is acceptable to the students
supervsiory committee. Ability will be determined by a
time-limited examination consisting of the translation of
a passage of literature or criticism in the particular

Back to top


• language. A dictionary will be permitted. It is possible
to waive this requirement only with the permission of
the Graduate Program Committee.
Ph.D. Program - Language Requirement (Addition)
All students registered in the Ph.D. program will be
required to demonstrate a reading ability in one language
other than English that is acceptable to the students
supervisory committee. Ability will be determined by a
time-limited examination consisting of the translation of
a passage of literature or criticism in the particular
language. A dictionary will be permitted. It is possible
to waive this requirement only with the permission of
the Graduate Program Committee."
Question was called, and a vote taken.
?
MOTION CARRIED
b)
Pat*r S.86-1 5 - GeoraDhy
Moved by B. Clayman, seconded by S. Verdun-Jones,
"That Senate approve and recommend approval to the
Board of Governors, as set forth in S.86-15, the proposed

S.M.06/Ol/86
Page 10
Graduate curriculum changes in the Department of
Geography:
i)
Reduction of M.A./M.Sc. course requirements for the
thesis option -
To: a minimum of 12 credits and (a modified and
renumbered) GEOG 800;
ii)
Modification of GEOG 800 (Introduction to Graduate
Studies) - ?
S
To: a two-semester course in which all faculty will
participate and in which grading will be on a
Satisfactory/Unsatisfactory basis according to
attendance, participation and submission of written
work;
iii)
The quantitative requirement for GEOG 407 be
changed -
To: GEOG 704 (Human Geographers) or GEOG 706
(Physical Geographers);
iv)
Deletion of the GEOG 301 requirement;
v)
The exDectation that Masters students present a
colloquium to the Department to discuss their thesis
proposals is to be stated as a re
q uirement. The
colloquium is to be presented before the end of the
third semester of residence;
vi)
Masters students will be required to circulate a
written thesis proposal to their Supervisory
• COmmittees, and make a copy available to the
Department, by the end of the third week of the
semester following completion of GEOG 700/1.
Written proposals serve to convey information about
• research plans and allow for feedback from all
members of the department. Normally, written
• proposals will be an update of work already done for
GEOG 700/1 and will be circulated prior to the
colloquium;
vii)
Delete the following courses: GEOG 802, 803, 805,
821, 822, 823, 824, 832, 833, 834, 852, 862, 871,
872, 892, 893, 807, 808, 809, 811, 813, 814, 815,
816, 841, 842, 844, 854, 881 and 882;
viii)
Introduce the following new and retitled courses -
GEOG 700-0 Introduction to Graduate Studies: Part I
GEOG 70 170 Introduction to Graduate Studies: Part II
• GEOG 704-4 Analytical Techniques in Human Geography
GEOG 706-4 Quantitative Techniques in Physical Geography
GEOG 708-4 Ideas & Methodology in the History of Geograpy

S.M. 06/01/86
Page 11
• ?
GEOG 710-4 Geography and Ideology
GEOG 712-4 Observation and Inference
GEOG 714-4 Computer Cartography
GEOG 715-4 Geographic Information Systems
GEOG 716-4 Aerial Reconnaissance for Remote Sensing
GEOG 717-4 Digital Processing of Remote Sensing Data
GEOG 720-4 Ecological Biogeography
GEOG 721-4 Biogeography of Wetlands
GEOG 723-4 Climatology
GEOG 724-4 Measurement & Modelling of Heat & Mass Transfer
GEOG 726-4 Fluvial Geomorphology
GEOG 727-4 Field & Analytical Methods in Geomorphology
GEOG 728-4 Quaternary Geology and Geomorphology
GEOG 730-4 Fossil Landforms
GEOG 734-4 Resources Management
GEOG 736-4 Resources & Environmental Issues in the Growth
of Food Production
GEOG 738-4 Water Resources I
GEOG 740-4 Geography and the Third World
GEOG 742-4 Regional Development
GEOG 745-4 Multinational and Regional Development
GEOG 747-4 Transportation
GEOG 749-4 Geography of Education
GEOG 752-4 Cultural Geography
GEOG 754-4 Landscape Aesthetics
GEOG 756-4 Historical Geography
GEOG 758-4 Heritage Resource Management
GEOG 760-4 Morphogenesis and the Built Environment
GEOG 761-4 Chronogeography
GEOG 770-4 Latin America
GEOG 780-4 Environmental Cognition
GEOG 781-4 Tactual Mapping: Theory and Practice
GEOG 791-4 Directed Readings
GEOG 797 M.Sc.Thesis
GEOG 798 M.A. Thesis
GEOG 799 Ph.D. Thesis
ix)
The course requirements for the extended essay
option be reduced -
To: 20 course credits
x)
All
graduate courses be allotted four credits rather
than three or five:

Back to top


. xi) The exoectation that doctoral students present a
seminar on a non-thesis related topic is to be replaced
by a re
q uirement that doctoral students present a

seminar on their research interests (and prior to
formally presenting their thesis proposal);
xii)
The Qualifying Examination will comprise a written set
of four (4) examiantions and a subsequent oral
defence. Where the Supervisory Committee deems it
desirable a field problem may be substituted for one
of the examinations. The field problem option is to be
dropped;
xiii)
Doctoral students will be required to undertake
qualifying examinations by the end of their third
semester of residence (and not by the end of the sixth
semester as presently required);
xiv)
Thesis proposals by doctoral students should be
presented no later than the end of the fifth semester"
S.M. 06/01/86
Page 12
Referring to the proposed reduction in course requirements to the University minimum, K.
Rieckhoff expressed concern about the trend which universities in general seem to be
following in this regard. He noted the importance of retaining the research aspect of
graduate degrees and went on to express his belief that this trend leads to a higher degree of
specialization and a reduction of breadth within and close to ones discipline. He also
expressed some concern with the practice of teaching graduate courses in a mode whim
combines them with undergraduate courses where both graduate and undergraduate
students are given the same lectures and materials, etc.; with graduate students being asked
to do additional work. He felt this practice, coupled with the trend to reduce course
requirements for graduate degrees, leads to a cumulative effect which erodes the quality of
the degree and should be discouraged and the issue and its implications should be addressed
in the appropriate forum. -
I. Hutchinson pointed out that while the Department is requiring a change in the total
number of course credits from 20 to 12, there is no actual change in the number of courses
required by the student.
In reply to an inquiry as to why the credit hours were all changed across the board to four,
R. Brown explained that within the Faculty of Arts the number of credit hours given to any
specific course is largely due to the impression faculty have about the amount of work which
is required in the course rather than to the relationship between direct contact hours in
class.
Question was called, and a vote taken.
?
MOTION CARRIED
c)
?
Pa p
er S.86-16 - History
?
C
Moved by B. Clayman, seconded R. Brown,

S.M. 06/01/86
Page 13

Back to top


• That Senate approve and recommend approval to the
Board of Governors, as set forth in S.86-16, the proposed
Graduate curriculum changes in the Department of
History:
i)
Areas of Study be changed
To: ... covered by the list of M.A. courses in the case
of M.A. applicants, or Ph.D. areas of specialization in
the case of Ph.D. applicants, will be considered for
admission to the respective graduate programmes.
The Department reserves the right to accept
candidates only when a qualified supervisor is
available and the University resources (including
Library facilities) are deemed adequate for the
students stated research priority;
Ia) Admission of Graduate Students be changed
To: Admission for M.A. students will be in the fall
semester only, and for Ph.D. students in either the fall
for spring semesters;
ii)
M.A. Conditions of Admission be changed
To: Candidates for the M.A. degree must satisfy the
minimum entrance requirements set by the
University: namely, at least a 3.0 average or its
equivalent. In addition, the Department requires a
3.25 average or its equivalent in the Major subject
over the last two years of the undergraduate program.
A degree in a discipline related to History may be
accepted in some cases;
iii)
Programs of Study for the M.A. be changed
To: Upon admission into the Graduate Program, each
student will be assigned a supervisor. For formation
of the Supervisory Committee see General Regulations,
P.
All candidates for the M.A. degree must satisfy the
following minimum requirements totalling 30
semester hours:
1. 20 semester hours of course work of which at least
15 semester hours must be in graduate courses in the
Department. Each year at least two seminars of two-
semester length (ten semester hours) will be offered,
one in Canadian History, the other in European

Back to top


. History. A third two-semester seminar may be
offered in another field when student numbers
warrant. All students will be required to take at least
one of these two part sequences of courses, HIST 806

S.M. 06/01/86
Page 14
.
and 807, or HIST 808 or 809, or HIST 810 or 811,
which will be available in the Fall and Spring
semesters. The remaining courses required to
complete the degree will be offered, in most cases
(with the exception of History 800-5 and History 896-
5), as individual single-semester study courses (five
semester hours each). Students with significant
financial support from fellowships or scholarships will
be expected to take a full course load each semester;
those with T.A.ships or R.A.ships may extent their
course load over a maximum of three semesters, but
will be expected to begin thesis research in the third
semester.
2. A thesis of 10 semester hours. Before beginning
the research semester, the student must prepare a
thesis prospectus which indicates the nature of the
problem, the availability and accessibility of the
relevant materials, etc. After consultation with the
senior supervisor, the prospectus must be submitted
to a meeting of the Supervisory Committee for its
suggestions and approval.
Under certain circumstances the Department may
consent to the awarding of the M.A. degree on the
basis of course work and extended essays only. In
place of the thesis, the candidate must complete an
additional ten semester hours in course work and
must submit to the Examining Committee three
extended essays, based on course work.
iv) Programs of Study for the Ph.D. be changed
To: Upon admission into the graduate program, each
student will be assigned a faculty supervisor. For
formation of the Supervisory Committee see General
Regulations, p. The Supervisory Committee and the
student shall determine three fields of study, at least
two of which will be chosen from the list printed
below. A third field may be chosen within or outside
the Department of History with permission of the
Graduate Studies Committee. The student and each
field supervisor will agree as soon as possible upon a
general list of readings upon which the field
examination will be based. No formal course work is
required. The written examinations in the three fields
will be taken in one two-week period and an oral
comprehensive exam will follow within one month.
Each written examination will be three hours in
.

S.M. 06/01/86
Page 15

Back to top


• length, and will consist of two or three questions to be
chosen from a broader list. A "fail', pass", or pass
with distinction' will be assigned to each field by the
field supervisor after the completion of the oral
examination. A student who fails one of the fields,
and one only, will be permitted to-sit that examination
once again. This examination will be in written form
only, with a second reader chosen from the
Supervisory Committee. The field examinations will
normally be taken during the student's fourth
semester of enrolment in the Ph.D. program.
v)
Thesis changed
To: Within one semester of the successful completion
of the comprehensive examinations, and formal
admission to candidacy, the student will submit a
thesis prospectus on a topic selected from among the
areas of specialization listed above. The same
procedure will be followed as for M.A. candidates, but
the Thesis Committee may seek the participation of
another individual who has particular expertise in the
area of the proposed thesis topic.
vi) History Graduate Courses changed - To:
HIST 800-5, 806-5, 807-5, 808-5, 809-5, 810-5, 812-
5, 813-5 and 896-5 will be offered as seminars only.
HIST 812 and 813 will deal with either the United
States, Africa, the Middle East or Latin America. The
other courses will normally be offered as directed
readings..
HIST 800-5 Historiography
*HIST 806-5 Political & Economic History of Canada: Part I
*HIST 807-5 Political & Economic History of Canada: Part II
*HIST 808-5 Social & Cultural History of Canada: Part I
*HIST 809-5 Social & Cultural History of Canada: Part II
t
HIST 810-5 European Social History: Part I
*HIST 811-5 European Social History: Part II
*HIST 812-5 Selected Topics: Part I
*HIST 813-5 Selected Topics: Part II
HIST 820-5 Tudor and Stuart England
HIST 821-5 Early Modern Europe
HIST 822-5 Modern Great Britain
HIST 823-5 Modern Russia
. ?
H1ST824-5 Modern France
HIST 825-5 Modern Central & Southeastern Europe
HIST 826-5 Modern European International History
HIST 828-5 European Cultural History

S.M. 06/01/86
Page 16
lIST 839-5 Colonial North America
HIST 843-5 United States to 1890
HIST 844-5 United States since 1890
HIST 845-5 Latin America to 1825
HIST 846-5 Latin America Since 1825
HIST 852-5 Twentieth Century Middle East
HIST 853-5 Twentieth Century North Africa
HIST 862-5 Modern Middle East
HIST 863-5 Colonial Administration in Africa
HIST 864-5 Tropical Africa
HIST 866-5 European Settlement in Africa
HIST 881-5 European Background of Colonialism & Imperialism
HIST 882-5 Conceptions of Colonialism & Imperialism
HIST 896-5 Supervised Research Seminar
HIST 897-5 Supervised Readings
HIST 898 M.A. Thesis/M.A. Extended Essays
HIST 899 Ph.D. Thesis"
(Secretary's Note: (i)
?
Denotes new courses; (ii) The following
courses will be deleted: lIST 805-5, 827-5, 835-5, 836-5, 851-5).
J
.
Little, History Department, was in attendance as a resource person but was not called upoø
to provide further information.
Question was called, and a vote taken.
?
MOTION CARRIED
d) ?
Parer S.86-17 - Political Science
Moved by B. Clayman, seconded by R. Brown,
"That Senate approve and recommend approval to the
Board of Governors, as set forth in S.86-17, the proposed
change in the degree requirements for the M.A. program
in Political Science:
To: Students will undertake formal course work and
write a thesis. The formal course work will include four
one-semester courses of which POL. 801 is compulsory.
Of the remaining three, students will be required to
choose at least two from among the core courses in the
academic program, comprising POL. 812, 821, 830, 841,
851 and 852, and any one course listed under Political
Science Graduate Courses. Students may also be
encouraged to take additional courses in Methodology
and Languages
.

S.M. 06/01/86
Page 17
T. Cohn, Chairman of the Political Science Department was in attendance as a resource person
but was not called upon to provide additional information.
Question was called, and a vote taken.
?
MOTION CARRIED
e) ?
Pacer S.86-18 - Psychology
Moved by B. Clayman, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
.
That Senate approve and recommend approval to the
Board of Governors, as set forth in S.86-18, the proposed
graduate curriculum changes in the Department of
Psychology - To:
i)
Application for the Experimental & Clinical Programs:
Applicants for both the Experimental and Clinical
Programs are admitted only in the Fall Semester.
Students seeking admission to either program must
submit all supporting documentation by the preceding
February 1 St. The Department reserves the right to
admit only those students for whom research space and
an appropriate faculty supervisor are available;
ii)
Delete - Application as a Qualifying Student
iii)
M.A. Program in Experimental Psychology: Admission
For admission requirements, refer to the General
Regulations.
Students must have accumulated at least 24 hours of
courses in the experimental areas of Psychology and a
course in Statistics in order to qualify for admission. Up
to six (6) hours of related courses deemed acceptable by
the Department may be counted toward the 24 hours of
Psychology.
All
applicants are required to submit scores
on the Graduate Record Examination (verbal, quantitative,
analytical, advanced sections), official transcripts, three
letters of academic reference and a statement of purpose.
Students admitted with a Bachelors degree will be
expected to complete
all
program requirements. Students
transferring from other graduate programs may petition
the department for credit for equivalent courses;
iv)
Ph.D. Program in Experimental Psychology:
For admission requirements refer to the General
Regulations.
All applicants are expected to have completed the
requirements of the M.A. program at Simon Fraser

S.M. 06/01/86
Page 18
University or their equivalent. Students admitted to the
Ph.D. program without this background may be required
to make up specified courses. All applicants from other
institutions are required to submit scores on Graduate
Record Examination (verbal, quantitative, analytical,
advanced sections), official transcripts, three letters of
reference and a statement of purpose;
v) Degree Requirements:
Required Courses for the Experimental Program
R. Blackman, Chairman of the Psychology Department, was in attendance as a resource
person but was not called upon for further information.
Question was called, and a vote taken. ?
MOTION CARRIED
MEMO.
Moved by B. Clayman, seconded by K. Rieckhoff,
That Senate approve and recommend approval to the
Board of Governors, as set forth in S.86-19, the revised
Calendar description for MATH 821-4
To: An introduction to the theory of block designs, finite
geometries and related topics"
Question was called, and a vote taken.
?
MOTION CARRIED
6. ?
OTHER BUSINESS
There was no other business.
'A-
There were no notices of motion.
8. ?
INFORMATION
The next regular meeting of Senate is scheduled for Monday, February 3, 1986.
The Assembly moved directly into Closed Session at 8:55 p.m.
W.R. Heath
Secretary of the Senate

Back to top