S
For Information
?
S.03-109
Annual Report on Student Discipline Matters
2002/2003
University Board on Student Discipline **
?
Senate Committee on Disciplinary Appeals **
?
Statistical Summary - Registrar *?
Statistical Summary - Director, Campus Community Services *
* Section 11.1 of Policy T10.01 states: "The Registrar and the Director of Campus
Community Services shall maintain a statistical summary of cases which are handled through
their offices each year, and these data shall be included in the Annual Report on Student
Discipline Matters."
** Section 11.2 of Policy TlO.O1 states: "In addition to the data in 11. 1, the Annual Report on
Student Discipline Matters will contain a summary of the UBSD Tribunal's decisions, the
• ?
President's decisions, SCODA's decisions and the penalties imposed. This report will be
accessible to the University community and will be submitted to Senate for information.
University Board on Student Discipline
?
Reporting Period: November 2002 to October 2003
0
The University Board on Student Discipline dealt with nineteen cases involving allegations of
academic dishonesty, and one case involving student misconduct in the period covered by the
report.
In addition, two requests from students were received to extend the deadline to file an appeal.
One was denied; the other granted and the deadline was extended by one week. The student
subsequently abandoned the appeal. Since the appeal was abandoned, the request did not receive
a case number.
A summary of the cases dealt with by the UBSD is attached for the information of Senate.
UBSD Membership
Faculty ?
Students
?
Staff
Past Members: ?
Current Members:
?
Past Members:
Joan Brockman
Co-Ordinator
(to October 2003)
Eng Choo
(to October 2002)
Tina Loo
(to June 2002 )
Current Members:
Howard Trottier
(to October 2004)
Terri Lacourse
(to August 2004)
Reza Pourvali
(to August 2004)
Lee Simons
(to August 2004)
Harry Yang
(to November 2003)
Caryn Cameron
(to October 2002)
Current Members:
Barbara Leighs
(to July 2004)
Yvonne Tabin
(to October 2006)
Donalda Meyers
(to October 2005)
.
Deborah Connolly
(to October 2005)
Aidan Vining
(to August 2006)
Professor Joan Brockman
Co-Ordinator, University Board on Student Discipline
?
is
0
C)
0
C)
C)
-
Z
C)
C)'
I-
C)
.
C)
0
0
-0
M
0
.
COO
OCo
-
CO
00
OC)
C)
o
CO
o
C)
ca ?
0)
0
E -
0
C)
0 -
00 @
0.
C)
.0
C)
C)
0.
-
E-0,
•
0
CC
-
2
01) 0.
0
C)00
CO
.0
C)
CO
C) ?
C)
CO ?
C)
. E
C)
CO
00
0
c.. ?
0
C)
o
.E
C)
C.)
OC)
C)
1 ?
C)
0
0
CO
0 -
-
•
9
00 .
CO ?
1...
00 -
O 0
C)
.0
> .5
0 -
CC f
00CC
00 CO
0
F-
-
9
C) CO
0
C)
C)
!
C)
.
01)
' ?
C)
o...
>
C).0
-o
E
0.
0.C)
C)Q
-
00
o
-
CC
C)
C)
-
(IC
.cI)
'..
C)
-
-
al
0
0 U.
C)
0
.0
C)
2
C)
C) ?
CO
9
(ICC)
:
0.CO
C)
;-. ?
C)
C)
(ICO
0
-
QCIC
.0
0
0
C)C.)
0
CC0
(ICj
.0
_
(IC
CO
C)
-C)
00
CO
r
•
0
o
fl
.n
CO
0
0(0
cr
- ?
C)
COO
co
000
o!
(IC
C)0
(IC
C)
OC)
O
I••
as
(0C)
M
OC)
=a
f5
02
-
C0
OC)
o
9
9
C)
CCC)
f--a
F--a
--
0
C)
C)
.00)
Ew
co
0
.2
.2
-
-
C) C)
•C)
0(0
0(0CC
(IC
•
C)
C)
.2
D.
EC)-
ow
oo
I-.
0
0.
C) ?
CIC
C;3
ca
.D
C,0
ca ?
0
.
-
.
C)C)
0.
C)
2
CO
-
-
-
.0
(IC
-
CO
9 C)
0.
wo
0
.0C)
C).
(IC ?
(IC
(0 ?
C)
.O
COC)
CO
E
C)
1Z
.-
CO
CO
C)
?
(IC
CO.0.0
C) ?
(IC
(IC
E
0t
C)
:-
((
0.
o
(...CO(IC
COC)
(0(0
COCO
C)C)
00
CO•Q0
t
E
CCC)
00
CO ?
CO
E
C)C)
C)
C)
In
-10
•
9co
9
Cl)
.0
f ?
0
C/)
Cl)
?
CO CO
Cl)
F-
?
F-
? 0.
C/)
C/)
C/)
?
CO
C/) ?
CO
C)
:
(IC
2°
2
(0
Cm
.
9
(0
C)
- C)
(0
•9
(0
.9
(0
9
Cl)
C)
.O
CO
(0 ?
CO
C)
9
•2
C)C0
C) ?
CO
-
C) ?
CO
C) ?
CO
0
(0
o
C)
I-
C)
wc
0
(0
.0
0)0
C)0
0)0
' ?
E
CO
C) ?
01)
0
2
.0
(IC
0(0
CO
In
E
.0(0
.0(0
.-
.0(0
0
C)
•
.
C)
(0
CO
'-
C)
0
CIC
C)
-.-0
-
C)
- ?
•
.9
29
0
0
-9
29
29
0
C)
(IC
-
.0
(0
C)
.0 (0
.0 (0
.0 (0
(IC
(0
k
-
•0
CO
C)
C)
C)
.
C)
C) C)
•-...
00
-
.°
-C•E)
0
9
Cl)
-. ?
C)
Cl) -
Cl)
-
Cl) -
(1)
o
2
0
ca
0
cc
CIC
C..
0
(IC
?
0
V 0
(IC
C)
(00)
00
0
C)0
(0
(IC
00
(IC
C)
00
00
o
0'-
0 ?
C)
o
o
0
o
0
.0 CC
-
.0
.0
.0 co
.0
.0 ?
CO
(IC
CO
9
M
;
5 E
M
W
La
•
0
•00
.C)
C)
. ?
C)
. ?
E . ?
-
.2 ?
x
. ?
.
. ?
.
.
C)
o
E 0
.-C)
C)
C)
-C) ?
00
C) 0
•
C)
C)
C) 00
00
Ii
'-
CO0.
CC0
C) C)
COCC
C)
?
0.
•- ?
C)
CC•
co
< .
9
<9
<
<C)
'/1
00
-
C)
N
C
N
0
N
0
N
0
N
0
N
0
0
=
L.
0
.
F-
L-
1
0
0
z
C)
CO
0
0.
CN
a)
a
C)
.0
-
cz
00
o
E
-
a)
C)
-
a..
2
-
E-
00
C0
ca ?
r-
C)
-
E
'
2
C)
C
C
0.
C)
C)
-o
C
•0
0.
a)tra
E-
aE
to E
.
0
0
tv
0
0'-
0
00
-
.9
.9
C)
a) ?
...
-
-
-
?
E
-
a) a)
-
C)
0
a)
a).
i- ?
C)
Ol-'
a) ?
cz
H
-
a
E
E
f_a)
0..
U
to
a)a)•
I- ? -
Cl ?
$-
-5
a) •
a) a).
0
cz
a)
-
.5
a).5
g
-a
0
a) ?
i..
.00 c
.
a)
-
-
.
-
2
.
a)
C/C
C)
0
a)
.
.
C)a)
.
E
-
C/C
-
0a)
a)_
0
0
o
?
.
.0.5a)
°-
Ln
0.
a)
.--
0
C
.°
o0
.
C)
0
.0
O0.
.0
f-a
0
vs
cn
E-a)a)
a) CIC
a)a)
-0.
•-a)a)
9
0
a)
C/C
a)-
-
.
0
a)
-
a)
=
Oa)
CC
0
CZ
-
- ?
-
0
-
?
2
-
C-.
a)
O.
.C/C
E-
C/C
a)
Ca)0
0.C)0
as ?
W
.0.0
OW
a) ?
C/C
a)
-E.E
EE
-E
•-
0.
C'3
c
o
ca
In
•02
-
a)
0.
a)
a)
.a)
-
0
tz
. -
. -
.-
?
a)
?
C/C
0. ?
.
0. ?
•
0..
0.
0.-a
0.-
.-
-
. ?
'
0.
?
0
m
m
u
0
"0
CC/
{a)
a)
00
00
00
-'
-
0.0.0
_
JU -Ui.
-
a) 0
-
a) 0)
00
0E
a)
a)
a).5
a)
2.a)
2
2.
2
-C)
f- ?
E-' ?
0..
C.ID ?
0
C#)
Ch 0
C.!)
?
W
(ID
?
0 4) ?
C/)
C/)
cz
0
C)
0.
0.
0
a)
-
-
2
-
_
0
-
-
0
E
C)
-
.9
E
72
a)
a)
E
.2
.
0
a)
E
a)
-
a)
a)
a)
4)
E
-
E
a)
-a
-
a)
)
.r
•
cu
-
ca
0
cC
-
0
2
00
00
0
.
.0
o
0
.2
o0
0
5
oa
•0
a)
C-.
cC
O
C/C ?
I-.
•
C/C
?
C-.
0
.
?
•
.
4)0
cC
. 0 C)
.0C)
a)a)
.0
En
2
c#
C)
r
W
0.
.0.
C)
2-
C/C ?
03
a)
0
WO
)
a)
a)
a)
Co
co
W
a)0
0
a) a)
-
9c
u
a)
0
00
.0
OC)c/C
0030.
.0
?
2
0
0
.0
0
0
.0
.0
00
a)
o
.0 0
o
.0 0
o
.0
4)C-
oa)
.0
-5
4) . ?
/C
C/C
C/C
C1C0
0
•9
C/C
c/C
.9
2
a)
5
a)
E
-.2
.9
5a)
a)5
a)E
a)
03
a)
-
-o
5
-
03
-
?
03.
.0
-
-
-
035
'H
Ill
C)
30
03
C)
C)
cCç
-
<a)
<
<.0
<i, <-o
e
°?
-
-
-
r'1
-
en
en
en
en
cn
en
en
en
C
en
0
en
0
ill
cdD
a)
0
0.
C)
0
a)
2
0
ca
4) ?
4)
- ?
4)_
44 ?
- ?
4)
F—
44
?
1..
4)
O4)c
4).
>
?
I- ?
4) ?
4)
oo
4e4
?
c'
Q4)
--
44
04)
44 ?
44
2
D-0
— a)
4)
0 ?
Cl,
?
I
-.
- ?
—
o
a) ?
CI
Co
0. ?
044
00
o-4
a)
I-I-
4)4)
0
I-
Ln
a)—.-
4$ ?
-
• ? C$
cl
Co
?
0
0—
a
.00I
ca ?
V
C.)
?
C)
-L)
a
?
tu
&E
a)
Cl,
a)
0
a
a)
.
E
C/D
Cd,
4$
0
44
44
-a
0
5:
(4
a)
4)4)
4)
4)4)
E
Cl,
(
o
C)
cn
a).—
.a)
• —
to
cz
•04)
m
ca
0
P.^
0
0)
(4
0.
Senate Committee on Disciplinary Appeals
?
Reporting Period: November 2002 to October 2003
The Senate Committee on Disciplinary Appeals dealt with no appeals in the period covered by this report.
SCODA Membership as Of June 23, 2003
Facult
y
Students
Karen Kavanagh
Chris Giacomantomo
Cyril Thong
Camilla Sears
Colleen Collins-Dodd
Josephine Wong
Sam Black
Warren Michelow
Cathy D'Andrea
Rick Yoo
Secretary:
?
Richard MacLeod
* ?
Chair to May 31, 2003.
Dr. Karen Kavanagh
Chair, Senate Committee on Disciplinary Appeals
S
0
and Registrar
in
.
?
Academic Student Discipline
September 2002 - September 2003
.
Type of Offense
# of cases
Departmental Penalty
plagiarism
7
penalties ranged from 0 for the
assignment to F for the course
cheating
17
penalties included 0 for the
assignment, letter of reprimand, or F
for the course
altering mid-term exam before
1
0 for mid-term
submission for regrading
Either copied from another
8
Penalties included 0 for the
student's assignment or provided
assignment, a percentage off the
access to assignment for copying
graded assignment, or F for the
course
Total: 33 students
November 6, 2003
0
Non Academic Student Discipline?
November 1, 2002 - October 31, 2003
Type of Incident:
No. of Cases:
Resolve:
Shoplifting/Theft @ SFU
1
No action
Bookstore
Harassment/Misconduct
2
Informal resolve
Disruptive Behaviour
7*
Informal resolve (6 cases)
(some disruptive behavior resulted
in property damage - only claimed
*I case to UBSD
one category)
Computer Misconduct
1
Informal resolve
Property Damage
0
Total: 11 students
M q ike
?
Dean *
Stu ?
'ervices
November
5,
2003
* Formerly the Director of Campus Community Services
S.
.
